

Jay Shetty & Dr. Lisa Miller ON Feeling Lost, Stuck, or Anxious?
In this On Purpose episode, Jay Shetty discussed the intersection between psychology and spirituality with his guest, Dr. Lisa Miller, a distinguished psychologist, Columbia University professor, and author of The Awakened Brain. She argued that we are innately spiritual beings, an ability which can improve mental health and resilience.
Would you believe that you were born spiritual, but forgot about it somewhere along the way?
In this On Purpose episode, Jay Shetty discussed the intersection between psychology and spirituality with his guest, Dr. Lisa Miller, a distinguished psychologist, Columbia University professor, and author of The Awakened Brain. She argued that we are innately spiritual beings, an ability which can improve mental health and resilience.
The Science of Inborn Spiritual Awareness
The core premise of Dr. Lisa Miller’s work is that spirituality is not a belief system or a theory, but a biological birthright. Her research revealed that spirituality is one-third inborn and two-thirds environmentally shaped.1 She jokingly told Jay Shetty that we are born with the hardware, but need to actively build the spirituality muscle through practice and by curating our environment.
In his career, Jay Shetty often noted that people feel torn between spirituality and science, compelled to choose one or the other. The truth is, Dr. Miller argues, that science and spirituality aren’t opposed. According to her, science is merely the lens through which we interpret our existence, and it can offer a structured, logical framework to support our inner guidance.
During their discussion, Jay Shetty noted that many people feel they must choose between being scientific or being spiritual, but Miller argues that science is simply a lens of witness that can validate our lived experiences. Science and spirituality are not antithetical; rather, science can provide a rigorous framework to support what many feel in their hearts to be true. Miller explains that specific neural circuits in the brain—an “awakened brain”—are activated when we engage our natural spiritual perception. This brain structure allows us to perceive that we are loved, held, guided, and never alone, which Miller describes as an inborn reality rather than a mere philosophical stance.
Spirituality Against Depression
In a society plagued by anxiety and depression, statistics show unbelievable data around spirituality. Jay Shetty’s audience learned that a strong spiritual life has an undeniable impact on mental health; Dr. Lisa Miller shared that being highly spiritual is 80% protective against addiction, 90% protective against depression, and 82% protective against suicide.2
Depression is just as much a spiritual misalignment as it is a mental health issue, Dr. Miller suggested. When Jay Shetty asked about the role spirituality plays in depression, the psychologist explained that it forces us to ask bigger, existential questions. When we wonder about the meaning of life, we come to understand that hardships also teach us a lesson from a higher power.
Achieving Awareness vs. Awakened Awareness
Dr. Miller believes that the moment we start seeing pain as a catalyst for growth instead of a dead end, we are one step closer to understanding our purpose. However, she differentiates between achieving awareness and awakened awareness. She distinguishes the two as follows:
- Achieving awareness is the brain's tactical part responsible for planning, executing tasks, and closing the deal.
- Awareness is the capacity to perceive guidance and deeper direction.
Jay Shetty observed that people often cling to achieving awareness because it feels tangible and offers a sense of control. Relying exclusively on this tool leads to a narrow, often unfulfilling existence, focused on the materialistic side of life. Embarking on a quest to achieve enlightenment can often feel too vague.
If we understand our brains as antennas that pick up the signals around us, we open ourselves to receive information and consciousness that exist around us. Contrary to popular belief, we don’t create the world around us, but we can perceive more than we are taught to believe. Jay Shetty and Dr. Lisa Miller agree that we are discoverers of our journey, rather than makers of our path.
Things Won’t Always Go Your Way
Dr. Lisa Miller invited Jay Shetty and his audience to join a visualization exercise, meant to reveal the right path forward. She used the metaphors of a red and yellow door, each indicating an opportunity. The goal was to help listeners identify a time when the (red) door they desperately wanted to open remained closed; instead, another (yellow) door opened and revealed an even better, more fulfilling, and more aligned opportunity.
Dr. Miller explained that we all encounter so-called trail angels, persons or events that guide us to the yellow door meant for us. The beauty of life consists in its unpredictability; she encouraged Jay Shetty’s audience to embrace the unknown and view life as a sacred adventure that we don’t need to keep under control at all times. This mindset also reduces frustration when things don’t go our way and makes room for curiosity as we discover which path the universe nudges us onto.
Don’t Underestimate the Meaning of Synchronicities
When you start treating life as an adventure, you also tune in to knowledge that doesn’t have a clear source. Dr. Miller explained that this path requires people to pay attention to synchronicities and treat them as real data instead of dismissing them as mere coincidences.
Dr. Lisa Miller introduced Jay Shetty’s audience to the three-step process for engaging with these moments:
- Authorize – open yourself to the information.
- Reflect – analyze the message that comes through.
- Act – follow up with real-life action aligned with the received information.
Jay Shetty pointed out that people often ignore these hunches due to societal pressure or busy schedules. This is why Dr. Miller warns that distancing ourselves from spirituality is detrimental to our well-being: the love and guidance are already there; we just need to allow ourselves to feel them and search for meaning in synchronicities rather than dismissing them.
Dr. Miller and her husband wanted to become parents, but the odds seemed to remain against them. Yet a series of improbable events and mystical experiences led them to an orphanage, where they found their adoptive son, whom they wouldn’t have otherwise met. She shared with Jay Shetty her conviction that spirituality is more than a nice feeling; it’s highly actionable guidance toward your true path.
Consult with Your Inner Counsel
In a 90-second meditation, Dr. Lisa Miller asked Jay Shetty and the audience to imagine a table and invite anyone, living or deceased, who truly has their best interest at heart. Then invite their higher selves and their higher power to join the party. Dr. Miller believes that everyone has a spiritual counsel, who loves them and would guide them in the right direction, which was the purpose of this exercise.
Jay Shetty’s experience was overwhelming and full of love; his spiritual teachers joined him at the table, even though he had never met some of them in person while they were still alive. Connections to ancestors and higher power are real relationships; scientifically, they provide the same neural protection against depression as any other form of secure attachment with a physical person.3
The best news about this Council is that it doesn’t have opening hours – we can always access it whenever we need. And, the more often we practice listening to their guidance, the easier it will eventually become to hear the intuition and make decisions from a place of love and calm.
Spirituality Doesn’t Make You Superior
However, being spiritual doesn’t make you better than others. Dr. Miller warns that spirituality and non-judgment must go hand in hand; otherwise, your practice isn’t truly spiritual. Spirituality isn’t a competition, nor a virtue; it should also not mean that you leave behind the people you love when you embark on this journey. Dr. Miller believes that we are all rays of the same sun, equally worthy of love.
But while we are all equal, we are not all the same. Both partners don’t have to be equally spiritual for a union to function; they’re not twins, they’re partners. Dr. Lisa Miller and her husband couldn’t be more different, yet their relationship thrived because of their complementary nature.
A marriage isn’t a contract but rather a calling, and even a single spiritual partner enriches family life. She jokingly told Jay Shetty that she is thankful for her husband’s deeper roots in the physical world, because otherwise their family would probably live in a tent.
Spirituality in the Workplace
Growing up, Jay Shetty often heard that money is bad, and he genuinely believed for a long time that spirituality and financial abundance can’t mix. It’s a widespread myth that leaves many torn between being spiritual and money. But Dr. Miller argued that abundance follows when we are aligned with our path; it’s not a transactional promise of wealth, but a sense of fullness that often includes having your financial needs met.
You don’t need to separate your spiritual and work life, Dr. Lisa Miller told Jay Shetty. Being spiritual at work can manifest in making more ethical decisions that are more sustainable and profitable in the long run. The Bhagavad Gita features a story in which the protagonist is told to fulfill his duty as a warrior rather than flee to a forest to meditate in the middle of a conflict, once more illustrating that spiritual and work life don’t have to be at odds.
Raising the Next Generation of Knowers
Kids are inherently spiritual; they are born as knowers and have a natural capacity for direct spiritual perception, Dr. Miller explained. However, modern schooling often teaches them to focus on empirical data and tangible facts. Slowly, over time, they become adults who have forgotten their spiritual nature and innate gift.
We don’t always know the source of our inner knowledge, but this doesn’t mean we must immediately dismiss it. Dr. Miller and Jay Shetty discuss a potential solution to the extreme rationalization of the world around us, which starts at home. She suggests that parents use spiritual language and invite children to join them on their spiritual journey, even engage in prayer or meditation together. Kids learn by imitation, and learning young how to tune in to their intuition will create the foundation for a spiritually rich life.
Suffering Has Meaning
Dr. Miller and Jay Shetty observed that people wait for something bad to happen before they are motivated to make a change or ask better questions. For anyone following the news, the current state of the world may seem dire, but Dr. Miller chooses to interpret it as the birthing pains of a collective awakening.
As she told Jay Shetty earlier in the interview, pain is necessary for growth; it’s a catalyst for change. Sit with your pain, and try to listen to your inner guidance – what does this challenging time teach you, and how can you overcome it and emerge stronger on the other side? Remember that not all red doors are meant for you, so let yourself be guided toward your yellow door, and treat everyone with kindness along the way.
More From Jay Shetty
Listen to the entire On Purpose with Jay Shetty podcast episode “Dr. Lisa Miller: Feeling Lost, Stuck or Anxious? (Use THIS Spiritual Framework to Finally Move Forward With Clarity)” now in the iTunes store or on Spotify. For more inspirational stories and messages like this, check out Jay’s website at jayshetty.me.
Disclaimer: The practices described are based on personal experiences and preliminary research. They are not medical advice, nor are results guaranteed. Individual outcomes vary, and some claims are still being studied. Always consult a qualified healthcare professional before beginning any new health, wellness, or therapeutic practice.
1Chapman, Amy L., and others, 'Awakening Education: Nurturing Spirituality in K–12 School Culture', in Lisa J. Miller (ed.), The Oxford Handbook of Psychology and Spirituality, 2nd edn (2024; online edn, Oxford Academic, 23 Jan. 2024), https://doi.org/10.1093/oxfordhb/9780190905538.013.8.
2Miller L. Spiritual awakening and depression in adolescents: a unified pathway or "two sides of the same coin". Bull Menninger Clin. 2013 Fall;77(4):332-48. doi: 10.1521/bumc.2013.77.4.332. PMID: 24354605.
3Miller L, Bansal R, Wickramaratne P, Hao X, Tenke CE, Weissman MM, Peterson BS. Neuroanatomical correlates of religiosity and spirituality: a study in adults at high and low familial risk for depression. JAMA Psychiatry. 2014 Feb;71(2):128-35. doi: 10.1001/jamapsychiatry.2013.3067. PMID: 24369341; PMCID: PMC3921896.
Sign up for the only email that puts purpose at the center of your day.


Looking for greater meaning? This quiz shows you how to live with purpose every day.
Take the Quiz
Dreaming of becoming a life coach? This quiz tells you if a coaching career is right for you.
Take the Quiz
Dreaming of becoming a life coach? This quiz tells you if a coaching career is right for you.
Take the Quiz
Everyone communicates differently. Discover your own personal fight style now.
Take the Quiz
Understanding your role in a relationship is the first step to making things work.
Take the Quiz

